For those of a certain generation, the idea of an AI therapist may seem like science fiction or something out of the cartoon, The Jetsons. According to an article in Sage Journal entitled “Artificial intelligence (AI) in psychotherapy: A challenging frontier.” “Artificial intelligence (AI) chatbots have emerged as a potential tool to revolutionize mental health care, offering innovative solutions for the diagnosis and management of psychiatric conditions.”
Imagine what it would be like to meet with a sophisticated system designed to understand the human condition and provide support and guidance in times of distress. For some it would fill a need for a timely appointment when a human therapist is not available. ChatGPT is one language used in Artificial Intelligence communication. It is programmed to respond to questions, like any language based A.I.
Below is a cheat sheet to explain what AI chat bots offer in the way of psychotherapy.
The main question of concern is, can AI safely and effectively do more than diagnosis and predict a mental health prognosis.
An essay in Psychology Today called, “Should I Use An AI Therapist?”, claims that “well known chatbots such as ChatGPT and Claude are already being used for therapy, and others — like Woebot, Youper, Earkick, ChatMind, Lotus, and Yuna — are specifically designed for it. Initially, these artificial therapists seemed to show promise.”
The downside to AI technology to provide the type of therapy offered by a human therapist is that it lacks the intuitive ability and human compassion that is part and parcel of the experience of meeting with a sentient being, instead of one comprised of circuitry that is pre-programmed for certain responses include pleasing the user by telling them what they want to hear and complimenting them no matter what.
The American Psychological Association, expresses concerns around the use of AI as a primary treatment form and published a document stating the necessary precautions.
Taking the discussion to the next level, a career therapist with 45 years of experience asked Chat GPT this question: Should clients seek out an AI therapist? The response was as expected.
“This is an important and nuanced question. Whether human clients should seek out AI as a psychotherapist depends on what they are seeking, their emotional needs, and the limitations of current technology. Here’s a breakdown of considerations:
When AI Might Be Helpful
AI chat bots can be a supplement, not a replacement, for human therapists in many cases:
-
Immediate emotional support: AI can provide a listening ear 24/7, especially when someone feels alone and just needs to talk.
-
Mental health check-ins: Daily or weekly AI-based tools can help people track their moods, notice patterns, and gain insights.
-
Access and affordability: For people who lack access to a human therapist (due to cost, location, stigma, or waitlists), AI can be a bridge.
-
Psychoeducation: AI can share information about anxiety, depression, coping skills, and mindfulness.
-
Therapeutic journaling and CBT-style prompts: Some AI tools use evidence-based methods to challenge negative thoughts or reinforce helpful habits.
Limitations and Cautions
AI chat bots are not licensed psychotherapists and cannot offer the full depth of human-centered care. They:
- lack empathy and lived experience: While they can simulate empathy, AI chat bots don’t truly feel or understand suffering like a human does.
- miss subtle cues: Human therapists pick up on body language, tone, and timing—important data that AI might misread or miss altogether.
- crisis response: AI bots should never be the sole support in emergencies (e.g., suicidal ideation, abuse, psychosis). It cannot replace crisis intervention or safety planning.
- trauma care: AI bots are not trauma-informed in the way trained professionals are. Missteps could cause harm rather than healing.
- lack of accountability: AI bots aren’t bound by licensure boards, confidentiality laws (like HIPAA), or ethical codes in the same way therapists are.”
Knowing that these are important considerations, you will need to make your own informed choice about whether to engage professionally with an AI therapist. If in doubt, select a well-trained, licensed experienced human therapist to assist you in navigating the challenges. You could consult your health insurance company or a therapy website like Psychology Today to find a referral for a therapist who would be a good fit.
60 Minutes addressed the issue of AI for therapy, for better or for worse.
For questions and information about starting therapy with me, click here.